Photo by Virgil Shipley

Cami Stidham, left, and her attorney, Harlow Walker, listen as Knox County Common Pleas Court Judge Eyster asks if she understand the charge against her and if she is making her guilty plea to grand theft of her own free will.

News Staff Reporter

MOUNT VERNON — Cami Stidham, scheduled for a jury trial today for an aggravated theft charge, pleaded guilty this afternoon to a reduced charge of grand theft, a fourth-degree felony. The maximum sentence for grand theft is 18 months in prison and a fine of $5,000.


John Stidham back in court

July 26, 2011

Stidham indicted for aggravated theft

December 8, 2010

The original charge, a third-degree felony could have resulted in up to five years in prison.

Common Pleas Judge Otho Eyster accepted the plea and scheduled sentencing for Aug. 26 at 9 a.m., following a pre-sentence investigation. Her bond was continued until that date.

The prosecution is also asking the court to require restitution in the amount of $180,000, which Assistant Prosecutor Jennifer Springer said is the same amount Stidham’s former employer, Tracy and Mills Surveyors, is seeking in a civil suit filed against Stidham.

Springer said she could not be concerned about what happens in a civil case, but it made sense to specify restitution in the same amount the injured party is seeking.

She told Eyster the reason she took the money was because she was the sole provider for her children and that she suffered from depression.

Stidham was indicted in November 2010 after an investigation by Mount Vernon Police Department Detective Craig Feeney into allegations that Stidham stole over $400,000 from her employer Tracy and Mills Surveyors, Mount Vernon.

According to the report, Mills had requested copies of checks made out to Tracy and Mills from ACS Title. Upon review, Mills said he did not see the business’ usual endorsement on the back of the checks. Because the checks were processed through a different bank, Mills followed that lead to a second bank where Mills discovered Stidham had opened an account listed as her doing business as Tracy and Mills Surveyors. A deposit reported Mills received showed about $46,000 was deposited between June 2, 2010 to Oct. 28, 2010.

She opened the account on March 16, 2007, as Cami Sue Stidham DBA Tracy and Mills Surveyors with statements using her home address, according to court documents.

Supplemental investigation documents indicate that Stidham deposited $405,699.03 between 2007 and 2010 with the following breakdown: $102,910 in 2007; $117,720 in 2008; $95,230 in 2009; and $89,839.03 in 2010. Monthly deposits ranged from $2,250 to $12,820.

Cash withdrawals from the account ranged from $60 to $500 and included countless business check card purchases for gasoline, restaurants, grocery stores, wireless phone stores, department and clothing stores and even payments to nail salons and the Lions Den.

Cami’s ex-husband, John Stidham, was charged with complicity for his role in the theft as well as many other theft, receiving stolen property and insurance fraud charges. He received eight years for a guilty plea to those 20 charges.

According to Knox County Common Pleas Court records, a domestic violence civil protection order against John was issued to Cami on Jan. 7, 2002. Just six months later the two were officially divorced. On March 28, 2003, child support and medical expenses were terminated because the two were living in the same household.



Joshua Morrison: 740-397-5333 or and on Twitter, @


Rules: Please keep your comments smart and civil. Don’t attack other commenters personally and keep your language decent. If a comment violates our comments standards, click the “X” in the upper right corner of the comment box to report abuse. To post comments, you must be a Facebook member.

2 Responses to “Cami Stidham has her day in court, pleads to grand theft”

  1. Tae T. Denimore

    It’s not the prosecutor, Miriam….?? The judge is the one who does the sentencing. The way I see it is every single county official I have come into contact with has screwed me personally. This county is a great big let down. People who abuse their children, send their children with strangers the children have never met or may never see again, children whose custodial parent does drugs and sends their children with child molesters have been brought to the light of both Judge Eyster, and Magistrate Williams. They have been brought to light with CPS, and Mount Vernon Police Dept. but nothing is done by them! These children are growing up with the idea that Mom or Dad break the rules and don’t have to pay why should I? That is what is so sad. This woman will be back with her children and they will see her actions. I hope she gets rehabilitated but I am sure I am not the only one who has great doubts on that one. I am sickened a lot at the thought of my county. We all come together when there is a tragedy but the rest of the time : under the rug. The good people are really the ones who suffer. I can be proud i work a minimum wage paying job, but for what if I can go out and steal loads of hard earned cash from my employer? Then I get to go to a place where there’s no men and eat and sleep all day. Sounds like living if ya ask me. Some how I am still proud I am one of the “good people” even if it means I watch all the bad around this county live with no repercussions.

  2. Miriam StJean

    Isn’t it nice to know 1) that one can watch their spouse (who has terrorized the county with home invasions over the last few years) murder someone and not get into any trouble, and 2) that that same person can, at the same time, rob her emloyer of almost $500K, only have to pay $140K back, and will look at only 18 months in jail for ALL OF THIS?

    Nice message you’re sending to the community, Mr. Prosecutor.

    Nice, indeed