Friday, February 3rd, 2012

E-edition
 

Freshwater Controversy

photo gallery
John Freshwater, center, addresses a sizable crowd on Mount Vernon's Public Square Wednesday afternoon, proclaiming his First Amendment rights to keep a Bible on his desk at school. With Freshwater are his wife, Nancy, right, and Dave Daubenmire, left, of Pass the Salt Ministries. Mount Vernon student Caleb McCoy rallies student support for eighth-grade science teacher John Freshwater, who on Wednesday was directed to remove a Bible from his classroom desk. A number of people stood and sat in the Mount Vernon Middle School library Monday night in support of middle school science teacher John Freshwater. They appaulded after the speakers who spoke in favor of Freshwater. Jeff Cline was one of the speakers in support of Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater at the Mount Vernon School Board meeting Monday evening. Cline read Bible passages as part of his presentation. Mount Vernon Board of Education President Ian Watson, second from right, reads a statement as the rest of the board, superintendent Steve Short and a large crowd listen at the Mount Vernon Middle School library Monday night. The crowd showed its support of middle school science teacher John Freshwater. A crowd gathered on Public Square, Sunday afternoon, in support of middle school science teacher John Freshwater's right to have a Bible on his desk. Early this morning, a group calling itself the "Minutemen" waited outside the administrative offices of the Mount Vernon City Schools. This photo of a student's arm with marks from an electrostatic device was included in the investigative report concerning Mount Vernon science teacher John Freshwater. The parents and student who filed the complaint indicated the burn marks remained on the student's arm for approximately three to four weeks. This photo of a student's arm with marks from an electrostatic device was included in the investigative report concerning Mount Vernon science teacher John Freshwater. The parents and student who filed the complaint indicated the burn marks remained on the student's arm for approximately three to four weeks. Mount Vernon Board of Education president Ian Watson reads a resolution saying the board intends to initiate proceedings to consider the termination of the contract of middle school science teacher John Freshwater.
stories
  • Eyster upholds decision to fire teacher

    MOUNT VERNON -- In a decision released this morning, Knox County Common Pleas Court Judge Otho Eyster upheld the Mount Vernon School Board's decision to fire former middle school science teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • ODE removes letter from Freshwater file

    MOUNT VERNON -- The Ohio Department of Education has removed a letter of admonishment from the personnel file of John Freshwater, an eighth-grade science teacher fired from his position at Mount Vernon Middle School in January. Read More

  • Family presents concerns about teacher's license

    MOUNT VERNON -- John Freshwater, fired Mount Vernon Middle School teacher, has petitioned the Ohio Department of Education to have a letter of admonishment removed from his file and to have his teaching license renewed. Read More

  • Freshwater fights admonishment from ODE

    MOUNT VERNON -- Former Mount Vernon teacher John Freshwater is continuing his fight against the educational establishment in Ohio. Read More

  • Rutherford Institute to assist Freshwater

    MOUNT VERNON -- John Freshwater, who, on his own behalf, filed an appeal against the termination of his teaching contract by the Mount Vernon City Schools Board of Education, now has legal representation. Read More

  • Board seeks dismissal of Freshwater appeal

    MOUNT VERNON -- Legal wrangling concerning the termination of John Freshwater's teaching contract by the Mount Vernon City Schools continues. Read More

  • MV board files response to Freshwater appeal

    MOUNT VERNON -- On March 8, the Mount Vernon City Schools Board of Education, through its attorney Sarah Moore, filed a response to John Freshwater's appeal of the termination of his teaching contract. Read More

  • Freshwater case heading to federal court

    MOUNT VERNON -- As far as the Knox County Court of Common Pleas is concerned, the John Freshwater v. the Mount Vernon City Schools Board of Education appeal is closed. The case has been transferred to federal court. (Court documents included) Read More

  • Freshwater files complaint with court

    MOUNT VERNON -- On Tuesday afternoon, John Freshwater, on his own behalf, filed a complaint, which could also be considered an appeal, with the Knox County Common Pleas Court. Read More

  • MV board terminates Freshwater's contract

    MOUNT VERNON -- After nearly two hours discussing Ohio School Board Association referee R. Lee Shepherd's report recommending the termination of John Freshwater's teaching contract, the Mount Vernon City Schools Board of Education voted 4-1 to terminate the former middle school science teacher. Read More

  • Referee: Freshwater should be terminated

    MOUNT VERNON -- R. Lee Shepherd, hearing referee, has determined the Mount Vernon City Board of Education has "good and just cause"to terminate the teaching contract of suspended middle school teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Referee to inform board, teacher of decision soon

    MOUNT VERNON -- The administrative hearing in the matter of the Mount Vernon Board of Education and suspended middle school teacher John Freshwater has been officially closed, according to hearing referee R. Lee Shepherd. Read More

  • Freshwater civil suits finished; termination conclusion looming

    MOUNT VERNON -- Although it started in 2008 with the suspension of Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater, the drama -- legal wrangling, court actions and Freshwater's contract termination hearing -- continued through 2010. Read More

  • Settlement signed by both parties in civil lawsuit

    NEWARK -- Documents obtained from the Licking County Probate/Juvenile Court suggest an end to the civil rights lawsuit filed by the Dennis family against suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater may be in sight. Read More

  • Freshwater drops case against school

    MOUNT VERNON -- On Thursday, the attorney for John and Nancy Freshwater and the lawyers for the Mount Vernon school board, et al., filed a joint document in the U.S. District Court to stipulate, with prejudice, the dismissal of Freshwater's lawsuit against the board, et al. Read More

  • Loss of consortium claim dropped

    MOUNT VERNON -- On June 9, 2009, John Freshwater filed a civil lawsuit in the U.S. District Court. Read More

  • Teacher questions what makes sense

    MOUNT VERNON -- Closing arguments, or post-hearing briefs, have been submitted in the matter of the termination of employment of former Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater by the Mount Vernon City Schools. Administrative hearing referee R. Lee Shepherd has many pages of material to review. Read More

  • BOE says credibility the big issue

    MOUNT VERNON -- "Simply put, John Freshwater is not credible,"begins the post-hearing brief composed by David Millstone, attorney for the Mount Vernon City Schools. Read More

  • Brief examines witness credibility

    MOUNT VERNON -- The public sessions in the contract termination hearings for suspended Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater are over; however, written briefs continue to be filed with hearing referee R. Lee Shepherd. The News has learned that an amicus brief has been filed by Douglas Mansfield as a "friend of the Court." Read More

  • Sanctions awarded

    COLUMBUS -- The U.S. District Court on Friday ruled on motions in the civil case filed by John Freshwater and his wife, Nancy, against the Mount Vernon Board of Education, et al. Read More

  • BOE wants lawyer sanctioned

    COLUMBUS -- Legal wrangling continues in the federal civil suit suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater filed against the Mount Vernon City Schools Board of Education and others. Read More

  • Freshwater asks for time

    MOUNT VERNON -- Timelines with respect to legal issues and lawsuits related to John Freshwater are overlapping, and apparently causing some difficulty for R. Kelly Hamilton, Freshwater's attorney, to meet the respective filing deadlines. Read More

  • Freshwater, attorney sanctions stand

    MOUNT VERNON -- On Monday, U.S. District Judge Gregory Frost denied a motion by John Freshwater and Attorney Kelly Hamilton and upheld sanctions previously issued. Frost is presiding in the civil case brought against Freshwater by the Doe family. Read More

  • No decision yet from lawsuit hearing

    COLUMBUS -- No decision was rendered Thursday at the evidentiary hearing related to the Doe family lawsuit against John Freshwater. Read More

  • Agreement reached in civil suit

    MOUNT VERNON -- The civil suit between the Doe family and John Freshwater has come to an agreement, according to a spokesperson for the clerk of courts for the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio, Eastern Division. Read More

  • Oral hearing set for Freshwater civil suit

    COLUMBUS -- Legal maneuvering in matters concerning suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater continue. Read More

  • Freshwater sanctions possible

    COLUMBUS -- Doug Mansfield, the attorney representing the Doe family in a civil suit against suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater, claims Freshwater should face ultimate sanctions for not complying with court orders. Read More

  • Testimony complete in Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- The hearing of witnesses and presentation of evidence in the John Freshwater contract termination dispute ended Tuesday. Read More

  • Short testifies about materials in Freshwater termination hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- The contract termination hearing for Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater resumed today with Steve Short, superintendent of the Mount Vernon School District, on the stand. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing adds another day

    MOUNT VERNON -- Tuesday marked the 37th day of testimony in the contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater, but, despite statements made last week, it was not the last. The hearing will resume at 9 a.m. on Tuesday, June 22. Read More

  • Experts rebut witness testimony

    MOUNT VERNON -- Two experts took the stand Monday afternoon as rebuttal witnesses in the John Freshwater contract termination hearing. Read More

  • Freshwater: 'Somebody's trying to set me up'

    MOUNT VERNON -- "Somebody's trying to set me up,"said John Freshwater during Friday's session of his contract termination hearing. Read More

  • Slideshow part of Freshwater testimony

    MOUNT VERNON -- Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater continues his testimony today in his termination hearing. Read More

  • Contents of mysterious black bag revealed

    MOUNT VERNON -- The contents of the mysterious black bag were entered into evidence Thursday afternoon as the contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater continued. Read More

  • Watson continues testimony

    MOUNT VERNON -- Former Mount Vernon Board of Education member Ian Watson remains on the stand this morning during the John Freshwater contract termination hearing. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing resumes

    MOUNT VERNON -- In recess since April 30, the John Freshwater contract termination hearing resumed Tuesday. Read More

  • Gag order placed on civil case against teacher

    MOUNT VERNON -- After Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater openly discussed a settlement offer from John Doe, et al., in the civil case against him, at the May Mount Vernon School Board meeting, Judge Gregory L. Frost placed a gag order on the case. Read More

  • Insubordination and other policies discussed at termination hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- The John Freshwater termination hearing resumed this morning for the first of five scheduled days this month. Read More

  • Students testify in Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Seven more students testified Friday in the contract termination hearing for suspended Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater. They attended Freshwater's eighth-period, eighth-grade science class during the 2007-08 school year. Read More

  • Freshwater takes stand in hearing

    According to Mount Vernon News reporter Pam Schehl, three witnesses have testified so far this morning at the termination hearing of Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Freshwater's motion to close hearing denied

    MOUNT VERNON -- The termination hearing of Mount Vernon middle school science teacher John Freshwater will continue on Thursday as an open hearing. Read More

  • Attorneys withdraw as counsel for Freshwater

    MOUNT VERNON -- New developments in the John Freshwater case could leave Freshwater without administration-funded representation a month before a civil suit is scheduled for trial. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing to resume

    MOUNT VERNON -- After a hiatus of about three months, the John Freshwater contract termination hearing is scheduled to resume at 9 a.m. on April 29. Read More

  • MVBOE attorney backed by judge

    COLUMBUS -- U.S. District Court Judge Gregory Frost ruled Thursday that David Millstone should be removed as a defendant in the lawsuit filed in June by suspended middle school science teacher John Freshwater against the Mount Vernon schools. Read More

  • Court rules on Freshwater civil suit

    COLUMBUS -- Nearly two years ago, on June 13, 2008, the Stephen Dennis family of Mount Vernon filed a civil lawsuit with the United States District Court, Southern District of Ohio, Eastern Division. The federal suit alleged civil rights violations by the Mount Vernon City School District Board of Education, the superintendent and middle school principal, and currently suspended middle school science teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • New board members recuse themselves

    MOUNT VERNON -- A Mount Vernon school board member since January, Paula Barone recused herself from Wednesday's executive session, which was held to discuss the civil suit filed by John Freshwater against the school board and others. Read More

  • MV board to hold special meeting

    MOUNT VERNON -- The Mount Vernon Board of Education will hold a special meeting for purposes of holding an executive session Wednesday at 5:30 p.m. to discuss pending litigation, John Freshwater et al., v, Mount Vernon City School District Board of Education Case No. 2:09 cv 464, with its attorneys. Read More

  • Anonymous source leads to 'black bag'find

    MOUNT VERNON -- Suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater continues to receive information and personal belongings from his former classroom from an anonymous source. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing suspended again

    MOUNT VERNON -- The contract termination hearing for suspended middle school teacher John Freshwater has been delayed -- again. Read More

  • Freshwater Termination Hearing update

    MOUNT VERNON -- The hearing session scheduled this morning in the termination hearing of Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater has yet to start as of 10:40 a.m. Read More

  • Referee intervenes in hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Returning for a second day of cross-examination, John Freshwater and school board attorney David Millstone frequently reached an impasse, prompting contract termination hearing referee R. Lee Shepherd to intervene at times. Read More

  • Validity of e-mail questioned in Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Ricardo Warren was the first witness during Tuesday's session of the contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Freshwater Termination Hearing update

    MOUNT VERNON -- Rick Warren, a Kenyon College soccer coach, testified this morning in the termination hearing of John Freshwater. Read More

  • Defense rests in Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- The defense rested its case to conclude Friday's session of the contract termination hearing for suspended Mount Vernon middle school teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Teacher continues defense

    MOUNT VERNON -- On Thursday, John Freshwater continued to answer questions during his contract termination hearing. Read More

  • Freshwater's science classroom revisited

    MOUNT VERNON -- Following testimony by retired teacher Jim Stockdale, John Freshwater took the stand on his own behalf when his contract termination hearing resumed on Tuesday. Read More

  • White testifies again at Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Over the objection of school board attorney David Millstone, Mount Vernon Middle School principal Bill White returned to the stand as Friday's sole witness in the contract termination hearing of John Freshwater. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing hits a button

    MOUNT VERNON -- Ellen Button, eighth-grade reading and science teacher at Mount Vernon Middle School, was the sole witness when the contract termination hearing for suspended MVMS teacher John Freshwater resumed Thursday. Read More

  • Defense witnesses to be called in Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Additional defense witnesses are expected to takethe stand when the contract termination hearing of Mount Vernon middle school science teacher John Freshwater resumes Tuesday. Read More

  • First Amendment discussed in Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- The defense continued to call witnesses when the John Freshwater contract termination hearing resumed Friday morning. Read More

  • Keib finishes testimony

    MOUNT VERNON -- As the contract termination hearing for John Freshwater continued Thursday, former Mount Vernon Middle School assistant, then interim, principal Tim Keib was back on the witness stand. Read More

  • Daubenmire testifies at Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Dave Daubenmire, president of Pass the Salt Ministries, was the first witness called when the contract termination hearing for suspended Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater resumed on Wednesday. Read More

  • Ohio supreme court rules in school board's favor

    MOUNT VERNON -- The Ohio Supreme Court on Wednesday denied the Writ of Mandamus application filed on behalf of suspended Mount Vernon teacher John Freshwater, and dismissed the case.  Read More

  • Court denies Freshwater attempt to force school board members to testify

    MOUNT VERNON -- The Ohio Supreme Court today granted the Mount Vernon school board's motion to dismiss the Writ of Mandamus application filed on behalf of John Freshwater. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing postponed indefinitely

    MOUNT VERNON -- The contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater, scheduled to resume Thursday, is again on hold. Read More

  • Freshwater files suit with Ohio Supreme Court

    MOUNT VERNON -- R. Kelly Hamilton, the attorney representing suspended Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater, has filed an application for a Writ of Mandamus with the Supreme Court of Ohio. Read More

  • ORC defines groundwork for termination procedure

    MOUNT VERNON -- The Ohio Revised Code, specifically section 3319.16, lays the legal groundwork for school boards to terminate the contract of teachers employed by the board of education. Read More

  • Further delays for Freshwater

    MOUNT VERNON -- In limbo since May, the contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater is still on hold. Read More

  • Judge explains denial in Freshwater case

    MOUNT VERNON -- In the continuing dispute between John Freshwater and the Mount Vernon City Schools Board of Education, Freshwater's attorney R. Kelly Hamilton filed a petition with the Knox County Common Pleas Court asking that certain individuals be compelled to submit documents and testify in Freshwater's contract termination hearing. Read More

  • Freshwater amends lawsuit

    MOUNT VERNON -- John Freshwater, the Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher who was suspended by the school board in 2008 for alleged professional misconduct, has amended the $1 million federal lawsuit against the Mount Vernon City School Board and various past and present school officials. The complaint for compensatory and punitive damages now lists Freshwater's wife, Nancy, as a plaintiff. Read More

  • Judge denies petition on board's testimony

    MOUNT VERNON -- In an attempt to force several Mount Vernon school board members to testify at the contract termination hearing for John Freshwater, Freshwater attorney Kelly Hamilton filed a petition with the Knox County Court of Common Pleas on June 2. The petition asked the judge to render a decision to compel their testimony. Read More

  • Freshwater amends lawsuit

    MOUNT VERNON -- John Freshwater, the Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher who was suspended by the school board in 2008 for alleged professional misconduct, has amended the $1 million federal lawsuit against the Mount Vernon City School Board and various past and present school officials. The complaint for compensatory and punitive damages now lists Freshwater's wife, Nancy, as a plaintiff. Read More

  • Freshwater files federal lawsuit

    MOUNT VERNON -- John Freshwater, the Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher who was suspended by the school board in 2008 for alleged professional misconduct, has filed a federal suit against the Mount Vernon City School Board and various past and present school officials. Read More

  • Federal lawsuit filed against school board

    MOUNT VERNON -- A federal lawsuit was filed on behalf of John Freshwater, eighth-grade science teacher at Mount Vernon Middle School against the Mount Vernon City School District Board of Education, as well as select members of the board, and administrators. Also included in the suit are Thomas and Julia Hurlevi, principals of H.R. on Call, Inc., and unnamed John and Jane Does. Read More

  • Dennis family wraps up Freshwater testimony

    MOUNT VERNON -- The Dennis family continued to be the focus of questioning during Friday's session of the contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Freshwater Termination Hearing: Morning update

    The contract termination hearing of Middle School science teacher John Freshwater resumed this morning. One of the charges against Freshwater is that he allegedly burned a cross on a student's arm during a science experiment. Read More

  • Student testifies again

    MOUNT VERNON -- Zach Dennis was the first witness called by attorney Kelly Hamilton when the contract termination hearing for suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater resumed Thursday. Dennis allegedly was injured by Freshwater during a science experiment. Read More

  • Freshwater Termination Hearing: Afternoon update

    Zach Dennis was the main witness when the contract termination hearing for John Freshwater resumed Thursday. Dennis reviewed and confirmed his earlier testimony, and demonstrated to the referee the procedure of the electric generator experiment. Read More

  • Freshwater Termination Hearing: Morning update

    Mount Vernon student Zach Dennis was on the stand this morning in the contract termination hearing of Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Teacher hearing resumes

    MOUNT VERNON -- Additional defense witnesses are expected to take the stand when the contract termination hearing of Mount Vernon middle school science teacher John Freshwater resumes today. Read More

  • Healing session discussed at Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Pastor Stephen Zirkle was the first witness when the contract termination hearing for John Freshwater resumed Thursday. Zirkle is the individual for whom an alleged "healing session"was held following a Fellowship of Christian Athletes meeting at the Mount Vernon Middle School on March 18, 2008. Read More

  • Investigative firm stands by its report

    MOUNT VERNON -- Julia Herlevi, co-owner of HR on Call, the firm which investigated allegations against John Freshwater, was called Friday as a witness in Freshwater's contract termination hearing. Read More

  • Ex-student disputes photo evidence

    MOUNT VERNON -- "That's not Zach's arm,"was the late afternoon bombshell dropped by Ben Nielson during Thursday's contract termination hearing regarding John Freshwater. Nielson was referring to a newspaper photo purported to depict the alleged injury to Zach Dennis'arm caused by Freshwater with a high frequency generator. Read More

  • Freshwater Contract Termination Hearing Update

    MOUNT VERNON -- "That's not Zach's arm,"said Ben Nielson, former student of John Freshwater, as he testified late this afternoon in Freshwater's contract termination hearing. Read More

  • Teacher, former superintendent testify at hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Former Mount Vernon City School superintendent R. Jeff Maley was the first witness called when the contract termination hearing of John Freshwater resumed Wednesday. Read More

  • Freshwater Contract Termination Hearing update

    Lori Miller, Mount Vernon Middle School seventh-grade math teacher, was Wednesday afternoon's witness in the contract termination hearing of John Freshwater. Read More

  • Former superintendent questioned

    MOUNT VERNON -- Former Superintendent Jeff Maley took the stand this morning in the termination hearing for Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Students testify at teacher's hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- The John Freshwater contract termination hearing on Friday began with legal wrangling. First, Freshwater's attorney, Kelly Hamilton, called James Baroth to the witness chair. He was planning to have Baroth testify as to an affidavit filed by Baroth's daughter, Melanie Dobson, who resides in Oregon and could not be present at the hearing. Read More

  • Freshwater Termination Hearing afternoon update

    MOUNT VERNON -- Friday's John Freshwater contract termination hearing lasted only half a day. Kelly Hamilton, Freshwater's lawyer, tried to enter into evidence affidavits written by former Freshwater students, with the students'parents on hand to testify as the authenticity and veracity of the statements. Hamilton took that route, he said, because of his client's desire to protect the privacy of the students. Read More

  • Freshwater Termination Hearing morning update

    MOUNT VERNON -- The hearing regarding Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater will resume at 10 a.m. after an adjournment to bring student witnesses to the Knox County Service Center. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing delayed again

    MOUNT VERNON -- The termination hearing of Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater has once again been delayed. Read More

  • Princehouse testifies in Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Dr. Patricia Princehouse, lecturer in philosophy and evolutionary biology at Case Western Reserve University, was Friday's sole witness in the contract termination hearing for John Freshwater. Read More

  • Student handouts subject of this morning at Freshwater hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Dr. Patricia Princehouse, lecturer in philosophy and evolutionary biology with Case Western Reserve University, is currently on the stand in the contract termination hearing for John Freshwater. Read More

  • Tesla coil demonstrated during hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- How hot do Tesla coils get? Participants and spectators at the contract termination hearing for John Freshwater saw for themselves on Thursday. Read More

  • State science consultant explains classroom standards

    MOUNT VERNON -- David Millstone, attorney for the Mount Vernon Board of Education called Joseph Faber, assistant professor of biology at Ohio University - Lancaster to the stand this morning as the John Freshwater termination hearing moves forward. Read More

  • Investigator's report examined

    MOUNT VERNON -- The cross-examination of Thomas Herlevi, owner of HR on Call, the firm hired to investigate allegations against Mount Vernon teacher John Freshwater, consumed most of Wednesday's hearing. Read More

  • Investigator questioned about tesla coil experiment

    MOUNT VERNON -- Kelly Hamilton, attorney for John Freshwater, continues to cross examine Thomas Herlevi this morning. Herlevi is the owner of HR on Call, the firm hired to investigate allegations against Freshwater. Read More

  • Termination hearing continues for Freshwater

    MOUNT VERNON -- The contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater resumed Tuesday morning with testimony from Dennis Turner, pastor of New Life Community Church in Fredericktown. Read More

  • Investigator cross examined by Freshwater lawyer

    MOUNT VERNON -- Cross examination of Thomas Herlevi, owner of HR on Call, the firm hired by the Mount Vernon Board of Education to investigate allegations against John Freshwater, continued after today's lunch break. Read More

  • Investigator, pastor testify in morning session

    MOUNT VERNON -- The termination hearing for Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater resumed today. Read More

  • Freshwater termination hearing to resume

    MOUNT VERNON -- On break since Oct. 31, the employment termination hearing of Mount Vernon middle school science teacher John Freshwater is scheduled to resume Tuesday. The proceedings will again be held in the conference room in the office of the Knox County Commissioners. Read More

  • Former Freshwater students testify

    MOUNT VERNON -- Dinosaurs, dragons and Darwin were discussed Friday during the contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Friday morning hearing update

    MOUNT VERNON -- Simon Souhrada, a 17-year-old junior at Mount Vernon High School, testified this morning in the termination hearing of John Freshwater. Read More

  • Medical expert testifies at hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Expert medical testimony was introduced during Thursday's session of the contract termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater. Dr. David Levy, chairman of the department of emergency medicine at St. Elizabeth Health Center in Youngstown, was called as a witness by David Millstone, the attorney for the Mount Vernon Board of Education. Read More

  • Thursday morning hearing update

    MOUNT VERNON -- Mount Vernon High School Principal Kathy Kasler took the stand this morning, following Middle School Principal Bill White's testimony. Read More

  • Second student steps forward at hearing

    MOUNT VERNON -- Another student came forward during Wednesday's session of the contract termination hearing for John Freshwater. The student, now a senior at Mount Vernon High School, testified at the end of the day's proceedings. Upon questioning by David Millstone, the school board's attorney, the student said he had Freshwater as his eighth-grade science teacher and learned, among other things, about electricity and evolution in Freshwater's class. Read More

  • Wednesday morning Freshwater hearing update

    MOUNT VERNON -- Mount Vernon Middle School Principal Bill White has been on the stand this morning, testifying in the John Freshwater termination hearing. Read More

  • Student, teacher take the stand

    MOUNT VERNON -- On Tuesday, the contract termination hearing for suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater resumed after a three-week hiatus. The Mount Vernon school board is considering firing Freshwater as a result of allegations of unprofessional conduct. Read More

  • Tuesday afternoon Freshwater hearing update

    MOUNT VERNON -- Jenifer Dennis, the mother of Zach Dennis, the student who testified earlier this morning, took the stand in Mount Vernon science teacher John Freshwater's termination hearing today at the Knox County Service Center. Read More

  • Tuesday morning Freshwater hearing update

    MOUNT VERNON -- Zach Dennis took the stand this morning as the John Freshwater termination hearing resumed after more than three weeks. Read More

  • Family wants to protect son, other students

    MOUNT VERNON -- As the contract termination hearing for suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater resumes, the Dennis family is speaking out. Originally referred to as the Doe family to protect their anonymity and to prevent negative repercussions, the family wants its side of the story to be told. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing to resume

    MOUNT VERNON -- After a three-week hiatus, the employment termination hearing of Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater is scheduled to resume Tuesday. The proceedings will again be held in the conference room in the office of the Knox County Commissioners. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing ends second day

    MOUNT VERNON -- The contract termination hearing of Mount Vernon middle school science teacher John Freshwater continued Friday with the cross-examination of Mount Vernon School superintendent Steve Short. Read More

  • Attorneys react to testimony

    MOUNT VERNON -- On Friday, after two days of testimony in the termination hearing of suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater, the legal representatives spoke about their impressions of the procedings. Read More

  • Short continues testimony

    MOUNT VERNON -- Proceedings involving Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater continued Friday morning with Stephen Short, Mount Vernon schools superintendent continuing his testimony from Thursday. Read More

  • Termination hearing begins

    MOUNT VERNON -- Space was at a premium for Thursday's hearing regarding the Mount Vernon City School board's resolution of intent to terminate the teaching contract of middle school science teacher John Freshwater. Only 21 spectator seats were available in the hearing room in the offices of the Knox County Commissioners, and a handful of people were waiting as early as 7:30 a.m. to secure a spot. Three Knox County Sheriff's deputies were there for security purposes and to make sure there was clear access to the other county offices in the building. Read More

  • Teacher's hearing starts today

    MOUNT VERNON -- The termination hearing for suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater began this morning at the Knox County Service Center. Read More

  • Teacher hearing postponed

    MOUNT VERNON -- R. Lee Shepherd, referee for the John Freshwater termination hearing, has postponed the start of the hearing to Thursday. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing to begin Wednesday

    MOUNT VERNON -- The termination hearing for suspended Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater is tentatively scheduled to begin Wednesday. Read More

  • Freshwater files counterclaim

    MOUNT VERNON -- Last week, R. Kelly Hamilton, attorney for John Freshwater, filed a counterclaim to the civil lawsuit pending in federal district court. Read More

  • New Yorker rallies in support of teacher

    MOUNT VERNON -- Not realizing that the termination hearing for Mount Vernon Middle School teacher John Freshwater was rescheduled from the original date of Tuesday to Oct. 1, the Rev. Ted Snyder and his family drove from their home in Rochester, N.Y., to Mount Vernon's Public Square to rally in support of the suspended teacher. Read More

  • Freshwater hearing postponed

    MOUNT VERNON -- Mount Vernon City Schools Superintendent Steve Short confirmed this morning that the termination hearing of middle school science teacher John Freshwater has been rescheduled. Read More

  • MV school board to fire Freshwater - VIDEO

    MOUNT VERNON -- On Friday, community members, school administrators, students, teachers and former teachers waited for more than three hours as the Mount Vernon Board of Education, in executive session, debated whether to continue the employment of eighth-grade science teacher John Freshwater.  Read More

  • Report reveals religion was taught

    MOUNT VERNON -- The independent investigating firm HR on Call Inc. has completed its investigation into various allegations against Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater. The resulting report describes the scope of the investigation and outlines the investigative process. In addition to reviewing various documents and Freshwater's personnel file, the investigators talked with a number of parents, other staff members, students and Freshwater himself. Read More

  • Group starts preparations for recalling board members

    MOUNT VERNON -- In a recent letter to the Mount Vernon News, M. Russell Erwin Sr., of the Knox County Chapter of Minutemen United, said the group had started preparations to recall the Mount Vernon school board due to its members'refusal to publicly answer whether a teacher in the Mount Vernon school system is permitted to have a Bible on his or her desk. Read More

  • Lawsuit filed against school, teacher

    MOUNT VERNON -- A lawsuit was filed Friday in the southern district court on behalf of a student at the Mount Vernon Middle School. The federal suit alleges civil rights violations by the Mount Vernon City School District Board of Education, superintendent Stephen Short, middle school principal William White and science teacher John Freshwater. Read More

  • Investigation nearly complete

    MOUNT VERNON -- Mount Vernon School superintendent Steve Short said this week that the investigation into allegations against middle school science teacher John Freshwater is nearing completion. Read More

  • Group repeats demand for answer to Bible question

    MOUNT VERNON -- After meeting with Mount Vernon school authorities Wednesday, representatives of the Mount Vernon chapter of Minutemen United have repeated their demand for a public statement on whether a classroom teacher is permitted to have a Bible on his or her desk. Read More

  • Group stages protest outside of offices

    MOUNT VERNON -- Early this morning, a group calling itself the "Minutemen"waited outside the administrative offices of the Mount Vernon City Schools. The group was reportedly protesting the administration's directive that middle school science teacher John Freshwater remove his personal Bible from his desk. Read More

  • Sunday rally on the Square (PHOTO)

    MOUNT VERNON -- A crowd gathered on Public Square, Sunday afternoon, in support of middle school science teacher John Freshwater's right to have a Bible on his desk. . Read More

  • Large crowd addresses MV school board

    MOUNT VERNON -- Monday's meeting of the Mount Vernon City Board of Education was well attended, and a number of community members addressed the board during the public participation portion of the meeting. Read More

  • Parents express concern about environment at school

    MOUNT VERNON -- Many Mount Vernon Middle School students have been vocal in their support of science teacher John Freshwater in his claims to a First Amendment right to display a Bible on his desk. But are those students willing to grant someone else equal rights to remain neutral or to disagree? -- May 6, 2008 Read More

  • Investigation under way against Freshwater

    MOUNT VERNON -- The official investigation into allegations against middle school science teacher John Freshwater is under way, according to David Millstone, attorney for the Mount Vernon City Schools. -- May 5, 2008 Read More

  • Tesla coils used to show electric current - VIDEO

    MOUNT VERNON -- Little information regarding allegations against Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater is being divulged by school officials or Freshwater. In an effort to further understand how a student of Freshwater's could be burned during a science experiment, the News met with Dr. Terry Klopcic, director of laboratories at Kenyon College, to discuss Tesla coils and their educational value in the classroom.-- April 29, 2008 Read More

  • What is your opinion of the Freshwater controversy?

    MOUNT VERNON -- Reader respond to the Streets question -- April 26, 2008 Read More

  • Experiments typical part of curriculum - VIDEO

    MOUNT VERNON -- Earlier this week, the Mount Vernon Board of Education announced it was hiring an independent investigator to determine if allegations against middle school science teacher John Freshwater were true. Those allegations include the accusation that Freshwater burned a cross on the forearm of a student while conducting an experiment using an electrostatic device.-- April 25, 2008 Read More

  • Freshwater controversy continues

    MOUNT VERNON -- Educational issues are volatile topics of discussion. Throw religion into the mix and emotions become even more explosive. The dispute between middle school science teacher John Freshwater and the Mount Vernon school administration and school board has spilled over into the community at large-- April 24, 2008. Read More

  • Investigation to begin into allegations against teacher

    MOUNT VERNON -- After an extended executive session Tuesday morning, the Mount Vernon City Schools Board of Education and administration decided to have an independent party investigate allegations made against eighth-grade science teacher John Freshwater.-- April 23, 2008 Read More

  • Teacher conduct subject of investigation

    MOUNT VERNON -- After an extended executive session Tuesday morning, the Mount Vernon City Schools Board of Education and administration decided to have an independent party investigate allegations made against eighth-grade science teacher John Freshwater.-- April 22, 2008 Read More

  • ACLU supports MV school board decision

    MOUNT VERNON -- Mount Vernon Middle School science teacher John Freshwater refused to move his Bible from his classroom desk after school officials requested that he do so. At a rally on Public Square on Wednesday, he defended his right to display his personal Bible as a constitutional right. If he's looking for the American Civil Liberties Union to defend him, he could be disappointed. -- April 19, 2008 Read More

  • Students rally in support of science teacher

    MOUNT VERNON -- Hundreds of students, joined by some parents and community members, gathered at the Spirit Rock outside of Mount Vernon High School in a show of support for middle school teacher John Freshwater.-- April 19, 2008 Read More

  • Students show support - VIDEO

    On Friday, Mount Vernon middle and high school student showed their support for middle school teacher John Freshwater and his quest to keep his bible visible in the classroom. -- April 18, 2008 Read More

  • Rally planned to support teacher

    MOUNT VERNON -- Things appeared calm and quiet this morning at Mount Vernon Middle School as students and staff followed their normal routines. -- April 19, 2008 Read More

  • Crowd shows support for MV science teacher -VIDEO

    MOUNT VERNON -- Nearly 100 people gathered on Mount Vernon's Public Square on Wednesday afternoon, in a show of support for middle school science teacher John Freshwater. The Mount Vernon City School administration has demanded Freshwater remove a Bible from his desk at school, even though a Bible has been a fixture in his classroom for many years. -- April 17, 2008 Read More

  • Bible in the classroom Discussion

    MOUNT VERNON -- Readers submitted their comments. -- April 17, 2008 Read More

  • Wednesday afternoon rally in support of teacher

    Nearly 100 people gathered on Mount Vernon's Public Square on Thursday afternoon, in a show of support for middle school science teacher John Freshwater. The Mount Vernon City School administration has demanded Freshwater remove a Bible from his desk at school, even though a Bible has been a fixture in his classroom for many years. -- April 16, 2008 Read More

Related stories
duration

1388 days since the story broke.

  • E-mail Story
  • Twitter
  • FeedBurner
  • RSS Feed
  • Sections:
    Local   Sports   Classifieds   Obituaries   Weather
    Online:
    Search   Site Map   Posting Policy   Privacy Policy   E-edition   Contact Us   Staff
    Services:
    Subscribe   Purchase Photos   Advertise
    Submit:
    Events   Anniversary   Engagement Form   Wedding   Suggest a story   Roll Call   Clubs   4-H   Vacation   Recipe   Problems
    Social:
    Twitter   Facebook   YouTube

    © Progressive Communications Corporation.

    Phone: (740) 397 5333 or 1-800-772-5333 (Toll Free in Ohio)